A Local Institution in East Orleans
Smitty’s Homemade Ice Cream sits at 210 Main Street in East Orleans, where the same owner has been making ice cream from scratch for over 30 years. Previously known as “The Sundae School,” the shop has become a Cape Cod tradition under its current ownership.
What Makes It Special
With 42 flavors made in-house, Smitty’s offers something for everyone:
- Classic favorites like Black Raspberry
- Signature creations like Nauset Mud (a chunky coffee flavor)
- Sherbets and sorbets for those avoiding dairy
- Sugar-free options for dietary needs
- Low-fat frozen yogurt
- A variety of sundae toppings from fudgy to crunchy
- Raspberry Lime Rickey (a refreshing non-ice cream alternative)
The Experience
The shop features a shaded, tree-lined courtyard where visitors can escape the summer heat and traffic. Being near Nauset Beach makes it a perfect stop for folks heading home after a day in the sand, though customers should note it’s cash only.
A Cape Cod Tradition
Smitty’s has earned its reputation through decades of quality and friendly service. The shop’s commitment to handcrafted ice cream and welcoming atmosphere has made it a cherished part of summer memories for generations of Cape Cod visitors.
The friendly staff and family-focused environment turn a simple ice cream stop into a community experience that keeps people coming back year after year.