A Chatham Classic Since 1997
Buffy’s Ice Cream Shop has been a Main Street fixture at 456 Main St in Chatham since 1997. Known for its handcrafted, small-batch ice cream and iconic pink bench out front, this beloved shop has become a tradition for many families visiting Cape Cod.
What Makes It Special
The shop focuses on quality and creativity with:
- Handmade ice cream in rotating flavors like Black Cherry Vanilla Chunk and Chocolate Chocolate Chunk
- Fresh-made waffle cones daily
- Cape Cod’s thickest milkshakes (made with 3 scoops of ice cream)
- Delectable ice cream sandwiches
- Refreshing Raspberry Lime Rickeys
- Vegan options for those with dietary restrictions
Recently, Buffy’s expanded its offerings with Chatham Ice Cream Bars, adding another innovative treat to their menu.
The Experience
The shop provides a charming setting with outdoor garden seating and picnic tables, creating what customers describe as a “cool atmosphere.” Wheelchair accessibility with ramps ensures everyone can enjoy their treats.
Visitor Information
Buffy’s accepts credit cards, making it convenient for tourists. While only street parking is available, its downtown location makes it an easy walk from many Chatham attractions and shops.
Buffy’s is a local favorite with a loyal following who return year after year for their exceptional handmade treats.