History
Founded in 2015 by a family from Sicily, Caffè Gelato Bertini brings authentic Italian gelato recipes to Cape Cod. The family transformed a former ice cream shop on Route 28 into a cozy café with terracotta tiles and vintage Italian posters. Though primarily seasonal, the shop has become popular enough to offer limited winter hours for locals.
What They Serve
This shop focuses on authentic Italian gelato and coffee, setting it apart from standard ice cream shops.
Popular Items
- Gelato Classico: Made daily using traditional methods with flavors like Pistacchio di Bronte and Stracciatella
- Sorbetti: Dairy-free options like Limone Sorrento and Fragola
- Espresso Bar: Featuring caffè macchiato and gelato affogato (vanilla gelato with espresso)
- Dolci: Homemade cannoli, panna cotta, and tiramisu
What to Know Before You Go
- Located at 1196 MA-28 D in South Yarmouth
- Primarily open April to October with some winter hours
- Summer lines can be long
- Good parking and close to Bass River beaches
- Accepts credit cards and mobile payments
- Has a loyalty program for regular customers
Why People Love It
Caffè Gelato Bertini offers an authentic Italian experience in the middle of Cape Cod. Locals enjoy morning cappuccinos and biscotti, while summer tourists come for Instagram-worthy gelato cones against the backdrop of Sicilian décor. The shop has been featured in Cape Cod travel publications as a must-visit for food lovers looking beyond typical seafood options. The family’s commitment to quality and tradition makes each visit feel like a small trip to Italy.