History
This newer addition to Cape Cod’s ice cream scene opened in May 2019, just in time for Memorial Day weekend. Located at 460 Waquoit Highway in East Falmouth, Captain Cone’s quickly won over both locals and visitors despite being a newcomer to the area.
Like many Cape establishments, they operate seasonally during the summer months when ice cream demand peaks in this coastal community.
What Makes Them Special
Captain Cone’s serves premium Gifford’s Ice Cream, a respected New England brand known for its rich, creamy texture. Their menu features over 30 artisanal flavors ranging from classics to creative options.
Customer favorites include:
- Toasted coconut (described by fans as a must-try)
- Cotton candy (praised for being exceptionally creamy)
- Mint chocolate chip (popular in shake form)
- Cappuccino chip
Beyond traditional scoops, they offer:
- Frozen yogurt
- Fruit sorbets and sherbets
- Italian ices for dairy-free options
- Frappes (New England’s term for milkshakes)
- Build-your-own sundaes
A thoughtful touch is their special treats for dogs, making it truly a place for the whole family—including four-legged members.
Family Business
Captain Cone’s is family-owned and operated, with a focus on creating a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Reviews consistently highlight the friendly staff and their willingness to go above and beyond for customers.
Their business philosophy emphasizes establishing an environment “where everyone feels at home,” which has helped them quickly become part of the Waquoit community fabric.
Local Favorite
Despite being relatively new, Captain Cone’s has earned a reputation for:
- Exceptional service, with stories of staff staying open late to accommodate large groups
- Generous portion sizes that offer good value
- Premium quality ingredients that justify repeat visits
The shop is located in the same area as other Waquoit businesses like Moto Pizza and Moonakis Cafe, making it a convenient stop when exploring this part of East Falmouth.
Captain Cone’s has established itself as a destination worth seeking out for anyone craving a quality ice cream experience in the East Falmouth area.