The Scoop on Smitty’s East Falmouth
Smitty’s Homemade Ice Cream has been making summer sweeter in East Falmouth since 1992. Located at 326 East Falmouth Highway, this original location has become a beloved Cape Cod tradition for locals and visitors alike.
The shop operates seasonally, typically opening in May and closing at the end of September. Like all Smitty’s locations, this shop is cash-only, so come prepared.
What makes the East Falmouth shop special is its charming setting: homemade ice cream enjoyed at picnic tables overlooking a pond, and the iconic retired trolley car where kids can sit while enjoying their treats. These unique features create a nostalgic atmosphere that captures the essence of Cape Cod summers.
Flavors That Keep People Coming Back
The East Falmouth shop offers over 30 different ice cream flavors made in-house. Fan favorites include ginger ice cream with hot fudge, cookie dough in a waffle cone, and their classic Chocolate (often called “the best around”). Other popular choices include “Shark’s Tooth” (chocolate ice cream with white chocolate chunks), and various Oreo combinations. For a local specialty, try Cape Cod Crunch – vanilla ice cream with grape nuts cereal and dried cranberries.
Their commitment to making everything from scratch extends to toppings as well. The homemade hot fudge receives particular praise, along with freshly made whipped cream and marshmallow topping. You can purchase hand-packed quarts to take home – perfect for stocking your vacation rental freezer.
The East Falmouth Experience
Eating ice cream at the East Falmouth location is more than just a quick treat. The grassy lawn, climbing trees, and charming building create a relaxed vibe that’s become part of many childhood memories. The trolley car remains especially popular with families looking for a unique spot to enjoy their dessert.
The entire operation moves “at its own pace,” allowing customers to sample flavors without feeling rushed. Even when lines form on busy summer evenings, the atmosphere remains relaxed and quintessentially “Cape Cod” in character.
For updates on seasonal openings and daily specials, check their official Facebook page (@smittysic) or Instagram (@smittysicecream).
Other Smitty’s Locations on Cape Cod
If you’re staying elsewhere on the Cape, Smitty’s also has shops in:
- Mashpee: Located at the rotary, offering a convenient stop for a quick cooling treat
- East Orleans: Known for standout black raspberry, ginger, and pistachio flavors
- Sandwich: The newest addition to the Smitty’s family