The Location
Smitty’s Homemade Ice Cream in Forestdale/Sandwich is located at 177 MA-130, in the space previously occupied by Sweet Caroline’s Ice Cream. As the newest addition to the Smitty’s family of shops across Cape Cod, this location brings their beloved homemade ice cream to the Sandwich area.
What Makes It Special
The Forestdale/Sandwich shop features outdoor seating, making it a perfect spot to enjoy Smitty’s famous treats during the warmer months. Like all Smitty’s locations, this shop is known for generous portions and high-quality, freshly made ice cream that has earned a passionate following among both locals and visitors.
The Sweet Stuff
This location offers the full range of Smitty’s classic and creative flavors:
- Brown Sugar Oatmeal: A unique, comforting flavor
- Shark’s Tooth: Chocolate ice cream loaded with white and chocolate chunks
- Cape Cod Crunch: Vanilla base with grape nut crunch, locally sourced cranberries, and chocolate chunks
- Raspberry Truffle: A customer favorite frequently mentioned in reviews
- Black Raspberry: Praised for its authentic flavor
Beyond Basic Scoops
Visitors to the Forestdale/Sandwich location can enjoy:
- Brownie Sundaes topped with homemade whipped cream
- Classic and Original Sundaes with various toppings
- Ice Cream Floats and Milkshakes
- Catering services including custom ice cream cakes and party trays
For Everyone
The Forestdale/Sandwich shop caters to various dietary needs with:
- Vegan options including raspberry and lime sorbets made with real fruit
- Non-dairy alternatives like orange sherbet and mango sorbet
- Several naturally gluten-free flavors, though those with sensitivities should verify ingredients in-store
Seasonal Charm
Like all Smitty’s locations, the Forestdale/Sandwich shop operates seasonally, typically closing for winter after the summer tourist rush and reopening in spring. This schedule aligns perfectly with Cape Cod’s tourism calendar, making each reopening a sign that summer is on its way.
A Community Favorite
In just a short time, the Forestdale/Sandwich location has established itself as part of the beloved Smitty’s tradition on Cape Cod. Smitty’s has been serving Cape Cod since 1992, growing from a small shop in East Falmouth to a multi-location favorite that spans the Cape.
When you visit Smitty’s in Forestdale/Sandwich, you’re participating in a Cape Cod ice cream tradition three decades in the making, now available in a new corner of the Cape.